ASTON/River Road Independent Value Fund (N: ARIVX) (I: ARVIX)
Fund Quarterly Commentary
3rd Quarter 2011
Stocks Plunge as Macro Risks Intensify
Equity markets plunged during the third quarter as investors reacted to a string of negative macroeconomic events beginning with the debt ceiling fiasco in Washington and the subsequent U.S. debt downgrade by Standard & Poor’s, followed by the deepening financial crisis in Europe and a general slowing of economic growth around the globe.
The broad market S&P 500 Index declined nearly 14% during the quarter, its biggest drop since the fourth quarter of 2008 and the second worst calendar third quarter since 1928. Small-cap stocks suffered even worse, with the Russell 2000 Index plummeting almost 22%—its second worst third quarter on record. We had warned investors about the overvaluation of small-cap stocks relative to large-caps for several quarters. That valuation gap collapsed amid the decline as small-caps underperformed large caps by more than seven percentage points (as measured by the Russell 2000 vs. Russell 1000 Index)—the widest spread since the first quarter of 1999.
Investors dumped both low-quality and high beta (volatility) stocks as the risk trade collapsed during the third quarter. Within the Fund’s Russell 2000 Value Index benchmark, the lowest beta stocks (first quintile) lost only 9% during the quarter versus a stunning decline of 36% for those with the highest beta (fifth quintile). In terms of quality, stocks in the top quintile for return-on-equity (ROE) outperformed the lowest ROE quintile by more than 13 percentage points.
From a style perspective, performance was mixed across market caps. Value modestly outperformed growth among small-caps during the quarter driven largely by greater weightings in the more defensive Utilities and Healthcare sectors. Growth still leads value by nearly three percentage points for the year-to-date through September 30, however, as the overall trend favoring growth has been broad-based. On a sector basis, all 10 economic sectors in the benchmark posted negative returns during the period. Utilities posted the least negative return, while Energy and Telecommunications delivered the worst returns.
Although a less favorable business operating environment and sharply declining market resulted in negative absolute returns during the quarter, the Fund substantially outperformed its benchmark aided by the portfolio’s cash position as well as security selection. Security selection has also been an important contributor to the Fund’s positive year-to-date performance through the end of September, which compares favorably with the index’s 18% decline.
Top contributor’s included Scholastic, Aaron’s, and Big Lots, all of which delivered positive returns during the quarter. Scholastic is the world’s largest publisher and distributor of children’s books, and despite a difficult financial period for both school districts and consumers it has reported several consecutive quarters of strong educational technology sales and solid book fair results. Management used its free cash flow to pay down debt, increase its dividend, repurchase stock, and reinvest in the business.
Aaron’s is a market leading rent-to-own retailer with growing customer traffic and positive same-store sales amid the challenging economic environment. Management also maintained its strong operating outlook and repurchased shares during the first six months of 2011. With consumer credit remaining tight, we are optimistic Aaron’s will continue to generate meaningful free cash flow and maintain its strong balance sheet.
Closeout retailer Big Lots reported a disappointing decrease in same-store sales, but management noted improving consumables and strong seasonal category sales. Since authorizing a share repurchase plan last quarter, the firm has reduced shares outstanding by 13%. Although the acquisition of an unprofitable Canadian closeout retailer negatively affected quarterly results, Big Lots reported year-over-year earnings per share growth due to its aggressive share repurchase program and tightened cost controls. Management believes same-store sales comparisons in the second half of 2011 will improve and continues to implement its store growth strategy.
ManTech International, CSG Systems International, and American Greetings were the three largest negative contributors to performance during the quarter. ManTech is a leading provider of information technology services to the U.S. military and federal government agencies. Although it reported a strong second quarter and reaffirmed its expectations for the year, contract awards during the quarter were weak. Management blamed the slowdown on delays in the U.S. federal government appropriation process. Given the uncertainty surrounding future government spending and a lower than expected book-to-bill ratio, we reduced our growth rate assumption and valuation calculation. On a positive note, ManTech’s balance sheet continues to improve and now has more cash than debt outstanding. Given its strong balance sheet, the government’s strategic need for a secure technology infrastructure, and the growing importance of cyber security, we are confident ManTech will survive the current downturn in government spending, thus the Fund continues to hold a reduced position.
Billing software firm CSG Systems has seen operating results negatively affected by a recent acquisition that has failed to meet expectations. The company also continues to suffer from price concessions on a recently renegotiated contract with DISH Network and further uncertainty stemming from the 2012 expiration of a contract with its largest client, Comcast. We believe we have accounted for these risks by using an above-average discount rate in our valuation model. We remain attracted to the firm’s high revenue visibility and strong free cash flow attributes.
Although American Greetings generated favorable operating results during the first two quarters of its fiscal year, management recently reduced its annual revenue growth forecast due to a more cautious economic outlook and a broad-based slowdown at retailers. Despite slower growth expectations, the greeting card company continues to generate strong free cash flow that it has used to reduce net debt, repurchase stock, and pay an attractive dividend. Because we originally used a lower growth-rate estimate in our valuation model than management’s lowered short-term guidance, our outlook and valuation assumptions remain unchanged.
Cash in the Portfolio declined from 48% at the beginning of the quarter to roughly 39% by the end of September. The increase in volatility in the small-cap market allowed us to take advantage of lower equity prices. Although we added several new stocks to the portfolio, the majority of purchases consisted of additions to existing holdings. We often increase the position size of holdings in the portfolio if their prices decline and their discount-to-valuations widen, assuming our valuation assumptions remain intact. Conversely, as the price of a holding appreciates and the discount-to-valuation declines, we will typically reduce the position size.
While the Fund remains defensively positioned, lower cash levels may increase the volatility of the portfolio in the future. If the smallcap market continues to weaken and valuations become more attractive, the portfolio may begin to increase its allocation to businesses with higher risk profiles. In essence, as the opportunity to earn adequate returns relative to risk improves, the assumption of risk in the portfolio may increase.
The largest new position added during the quarter was insurance firm Brown & Brown. The firm’s commissions are a product of exposure units and insurance rates. Unfortunately, both have declined significantly during the last several years due to price competition among insurers and, more recently, the struggling domestic economy. The deflationary pressure on insurance premiums has caused the firm to experience negative organic growth since 2007. Despite these well-known challenges, Brown & Brown continues to generate strong margins and cash flow thanks to management’s focus on expense control. Consequently, Brown & Brown’s balance sheet has improved in recent years and now has more cash than debt. Management’s patience has better positioned the company to make acquisitions to enhance growth, as it has done in the past, as valuations become more attractive.
Based on the commentaries from the approximately 300 small-cap businesses that we follow, we believe the economy has transitioned from a period of slow growth to slow-to-no-growth. The operating environment remains uncertain and management teams continue to experience difficulty planning and forecasting their businesses. Rising costs have reduced the margins of businesses we follow and higher prices have caused some demand destruction. In general, capital expenditures remain focused on short-term paybacks and increased productivity. The focus on productivity has enabled many businesses to maintain attractive margins, but it also has contributed to the stubbornly high unemployment rate. Several companies have also noted a slowdown in government spending, putting further pressure on end demand. Year-over-year earnings growth became more challenging during the second quarter and we expect earnings comparisons to remain increasingly difficult as companies report third quarter results. Although the business environment is uncertain for the companies we follow, we have not noticed a sharp decline in demand that would resemble the 2008-2009 recessionary period.
Given this environment, it remains extremely important that the portfolio follows its risk management discipline of only taking risk when appropriately compensated. When studying an individual business, we categorize the major forms of risk as operating and financial. Our definition of operating risk is the degree of volatility of a business’s future free cash flows. The more volatile or uncertain the future free cash flows, the higher the operating risk. We measure financial risk by the degree of leverage on a firm’s balance sheet relative to free cash flow.
When small-cap valuations appear high and we believe investors are not adequately compensated to assume risk, we attempt toa void both operating and financial risk. When small-cap valuations are attractive and risk is being priced appropriately, as an opportunistic strategy we are comfortable taking measured risk. In an attempt to limit large mistakes that could jeopardize absolute return, however, when assuming risk on a small-cap investment we will take only operating OR financial risk—never both.
Earlier this year, we did not believe risk was being priced properly in the small-cap market and positioned the Fund accordingly. Ino ur opinion, the portfolio’s equity holdings possessed below average levels of operating and financial risk. We believe this positioning benefited the performance of the equities held year-to-date. The pricing of risk changed considerably during the third quarter and is now more favorable for the purchaser of risk. Although we have not significantly altered the risk profile of the portfolio, we are considering several small-cap businesses that may have either volatility in their cash flows (operating risk) OR higher leverage on their balance sheet (financial risk). We do not believe that current prices for the universe of small-cap equities will cause us to become aggressively positioned at this time, but assuming volatility increases and the pricing of risk becomes even more favorable, we may increase the amount of holdings with higher risk profiles.
We manage this Fund in a manner that is flexible and opportunistic and will only assume risk when we believe we are being adequately compensated. The time to increase risk in the portfolio could be approaching, and we believe we are well positioned to take advantage of further increases in volatility in the small-cap market.
River Road Asset Management
5 October 2011
As of September 30, 2011, Scholastic comprised 0.26% of the portfolio’s assets, Aaron Group’s – 0.14%, Big Lots – 1.30%, ManTech International – 1.97%, CSG Systems International – 1.90%, American Greetings – 2.11%, and Brown & Brown – 3.19%. Note: Small-cap stocks are considered riskier than large-cap stocks due to greater potential volatility and less liquidity. Value investing often involves buying the stocks of companies that are currently out of favor that may decline further. Parameters set by the Subadviser are not a fundamental policy of the Fund and are subject to change at any time. Before investing, carefully consider the fund’s investment objectives, risks, charges and expenses. Contact 800 992-8151 for a prospectus containing this and other information. Read it carefully. Aston Funds are distributed by BNY Mellon Distributors Inc.